It has been the second case this
year. A couple of days ago, a number of newspapers reported the fact that the
MLA Mickky Pacheco had accused the Superintendent of Police, Mr. Allen D’Sa of
being a Portuguese national. The earlier instance of such a case, was that of
Ms. Valanka Alemão accusing her rival in the legislative assembly
elections, MLA Caetano Silva, of being a Portuguese national, and hence
incapable of representing the constituency of Benaulim.
On the face of it, it appears
that both these accusations are unfortunate since what they are in effect doing
is to ruin the public secret that is allowing a number of average (the
popularly phrased aam aadmi) Goans to
find jobs overseas, especially in Europe, and better their life chances and
those of their children. By creating a public controversy about the possibility
that these two men hold citizenship status in another State, what these two
cases will effectively do, is draw the energies of the Indian State bureaucracy
toward rooting out those Goans who hold dual citizenship. On second glance
however, perhaps Ms. Alemão and Mr. Pacheco are doing the Goan population a favour
since they are in effect creating the circumstances under which the Goan
citizenry will have to sit up and take charge of the situation that is in
effect a sword of Damocles that hangs over the heads of those who have
reclaimed their Portuguese citizenship. It has been all very well that until
now the enforcement by the authorities has been less than rigorous.However, as Prabhakar Timble recently pointed
out in his article in the Navhind Times, in addition to these two cases, there
were also at least four cases where persons were debarred from participating in
panchayat elections for reasons of holding Portuguese citizenship. The threat
it seems, comes not from a possibly dispassionate citizenry, but from jealous
neighbours, rivals in political contests or other familial or economic
contests. We should not forget that the current legal regime not only prevents
a foreign national from holding political office, but also prevents a foreign
national from holding agricultural property, a situation that could possibly be
used in the bitter inheritance battles that are such a marked feature of any
reasonably landed family. There are good reasons necessitating therefore, a
united popular response to this situation.
Fortunately for those interested
in presenting a challenge to the legal regime concerning nationality, asserting
their traditional and inheritable right to claim Portuguese citizenship, there
already exits a somewhat active group that should logically support the right
of the Goan to bear dual citizenship. For some years now, not merely citizen
groups, but legislators and Members of Parliament have been demanding, through
constitutional amendment, the grant of Special Status to Goa. One of the many
arguments that have been marshaled for the demand of Special Status has been
that this Special Status, where only Goans may purchase and trade in Goan land,
is necessary to protect Goan identity. More recently, our Chief Minister
Manohar Parrikar, also raised a similar issue of restricting the entry of migrants into the State to protect the same threatened Goan identity.
Upon raising this issue, Mr.
Parrikar drew flak from a number of locations, and was charged with being anti-national, and secessionist. To charge a member of the RSS, with being
anti-national and secessionist is laughable. But perhaps these charges were required
to demonstrate the manner in which all too often the anti-national argument is
irresponsibly flung despite the indubitable patriotism of the individual, and
the justice of their demand. The argument that is being made is not a
secessionist demand, on the contrary, it is one that needs to understand a
particular history. This history was reportedly often called upon by the late
Mathany Saldanha in his own arguments for Special Status for Goa. The argument
of activists such as him were to point out that given that Goa was integrated
into the Indian Union only in 1961, there were no Goan representative in the
Constituent Assembly to secure Goan interests. As we know, right from the
inception of Goa’s identity as a part of the Indian State, there have been
movements that have sought to protect the identity of Goa. As such, they argue,
it is now time for us to obtain Special Status, just like other smaller and
threatened parts of the Indian State, to protect Goan identity in the face of
inundation by larger forces.
The argument made by this segment
of those demanding Special Status for Goa, can also be used to accommodate the
right of Goans to hold dual nationality. If they point out that there were no
representatives in the Constituent Assembly to represent Goan interests at the
time of the framing of the Constitution, then it should also be underlined that
the integration Goa into the Indian Union was a largely unilateral act by the
Union of India, that did not respect the specificity of Goa. Indeed, as if to
underline this fact, despite Nehru’s assurances, the protection of the
specificity of Goa has had to be fought for in pitched battles every twenty
years; 1967, 19 86-7, and since 2006.
As the article by Prabhakar
Timble pointed out, the right to citizenship that Goans (and other persons from
former Portuguese territories in India) enjoy is not some post-Liberation gift
granted to them by the Government of Portugal, but the continuation of their
legal rights from prior to the Indian action in 1961. As Timble also pointed
out, if a number of Goans are utilizing this option today, it is not
necessarily out of any jealous love for Portugal, but to better their socio-economic
prospects. Indeed, many of those utilizing the option to regain their
Portuguese citizenship continue to invest in Goa, both economically as well as
emotionally. The issue of Indian insecurity in the face of citizens with dual
citizenship therefore, should hardly arise, at least not in the Indo-Portuguese
case (for remember we are speaking of more than just the Goans in this case).
As regular readers of this column
will recollect, I have not been a supporter of the move for Special Status forGoa. This objection has been based on the fact that there has been no clear
articulation of what this Special Status would mean, and what it would contain.
The only consistent demand has been to restrict the ownership of land to Goans
alone. This one clause will benefit, as this column has argued before, only
those who currently own vast tracts of land. It will not benefit the average
Goan. On the contrary it would possibly worsen their situation. However, it is
clear that there are significant segments of the Goan population that are
determined to gain Special Status for Goa. In such a case then, it would make
sense, in keeping with the strain of arguments referred to above, that they
also take up the cause of the right of Goans to retaining Indian citizenship,
while reclaiming their Portuguese citizenship. To do so, would ensure that the
interests of a large segment of blue collar Goans would not lose out on their
domestic interests while pursuing overseas their dreams for their family’s
welfare.
(A version of this post first appeared on the Gomantak Times 26 Sept 2012)
Errata: A paragraph above reads "We should not forget that the current legal regime not only prevents
a foreign national from holding political office, but also prevents a foreign
national from holding agricultural property, a situation that could possibly be
used in the bitter inheritance battles that are such a marked feature of any
reasonably landed family."
This is a mistaken representation. The regulations prevent a purchase of agricultural property by Persons of Indian Origin. Further, there may not be a sound basis to suggest that agricultural property cannot be inherited.
Given that the past week or so in Goa has been of torrid sexual drama, it seemed appropriate that this column too jump into the fray. Most sexual stories get told from the male point of view, and this story will be no exception. Where this narration will differ however, is how this particular male gets treated. In this story, the narrator is victim, rather than the victor or voyeur.
My story begins onboard a Kadamba shuttle service between Mapusa and Panjim. Not left with much seating choice, I moved to the back of the bus where the 5 seater held three men. There was a young man in his mid-twenties on one side, a possible 10 – 12 grader boy dressed in shorts on the other. In the centre was a rather personable young man in his late twenties to early thirties. No sooner had I settled down, than he flashed me a charming smile, asking “newspaper?” Given that I was fortuitously carrying one in my bag I handed him the newspaper. He flashed me another broad grin while asking me where I was from; “Goa?” I rolled my eyes, and responded, rather aggressively, that I was from Goa “Why? Don’t I look Goan?”
Having thus beaten him to silence, I retreated into my own personal world as we bumped our way toward Panjim. A couple of seconds later he gamely slid away from me and slapped the seat space between the two of us. Since I had managed, in the process of seating myself, to get squashed between this charmer and the twenty-something young man, I thought that the ‘charmer’ was making more space for me. A few seconds later however, I realized that the charmer had slid over merely to create space for the huge bag that the boy, on the other side of the seat, was carrying on his lap. Trying to make the best of the situation, I decided a couple of minutes later to use the bag as an arm-rest. Imagine my horror when I saw, as I turned around, the use my newspaper was being put to! Our charmer has ensured that while his hand away from me was holding the newspaper, it was also resting on the bare thigh of the young boy. The other hand was using the newspaper to screen this circumstance from the rest of the bus should they choose to look back.
‘Ok buster’, I thought to myself narrowing my eyes ‘I know what you’re up to!’ The boy though seemed oblivious to the location of the Charmer’s hand and was babbling away breathlessly. Taking this for some kind of consent from the boy, I looked away and decided (I now think wrongly) to mind my own business. A couple of minutes later, the charmer was back by my side, another winning smile, returning my newspaper and making small talk. After some perfunctory small talk about the location of where one should store cell phones on one’s person, I dove into the newspaper shutting him out of my space.
Now you have to remember that all this while we continue to bump our way towards Panjim. In the course of this ride, as I struggle to keep my eyes on the newsprint, I am convinced that the charmer’s hand is grazing my wrist rather deliberately and insistently. Since I don’t want to jump to conclusions, I decide that it’s just a result of the journey and my now hyperactive imagination. This state of mind lasts until with the next bump when the charmer’s hand is lightly, but quite surely around my wrist!
“How does one respond to this situation”, I asked myself as I pretended to focus on the paper. First the whole situation is rather and obviously embarrassing, and secondly, while I didn’t appreciate the sexual attention, I didn’t want to be the guy who initiates a session of old-fashioned gay- bashing. Fortunately for me I managed resolved the situation by quickly and deftly lifting his hand off my wrist, placing it on the bag and continuing to read the paper. The charmer mumbled ‘I’m sorry’ (not that I believed he was) and I feigned a distracted nod indicating that it was nothing as I pretended to be immersed in the newspaper. We reached Panjim without further incident and none of those winning smiles from the charmer.
While the power dimensions between two men are somewhat different as that between a woman and a man, I was nevertheless able to estimate something of the position women are placed in when they encounter such unsolicited sexual advances. For starters, one asks oneself whether one has given any indication that we are open to these attentions. I knew enough in this case to say that indeed I did not. The second issue one has to deal with is how, does one fend this person off. Invariably in the case of men propositioning women, the issue is not really a desire for sexual relation as much as it is the desire for conquest. In societies like ours, where the ideal male is seen as a hunter, it is through conquest that the male becomes in fact a Man. For the woman to indicate displeasure, and not be backed up by a crowd therefore, is to perhaps invite renewed and redoubled advances. Like I indicated earlier, between men the power equation is rather different (though this really does not hold for the charmer’s interaction with the boy), but one is still placed in the delicate, and for most men unique, situation of having to resolve the issue. When the expected social role for men is to be the hunter, rather than the hunted, such unwelcome sexual advances are invariably responded to with violence. For the gender and politically sensitive however, this is not really an option. Such a route merely re-inscribes the dominant expectation of what it is to be a man, and perpetuates homophobia. To resolve this situation through public shaming without violence, is to court becoming the butt of public ridicule. After all it isn’t particularly manly to be seen as attractive to other men, even if you have not been sending out any signals. Besides, in using shame and not violence, one is not really using one’s male prerogative of violence, and displaying in this manner, one’s lack of masculinity and therefore culpability.
As the Pacheco story develops perhaps we will realize that there are deeper and more devious political games being played. However in the interim it would be worthwhile to contemplate the manner in which the sexual practices of our society, that is the manner in which sexuality, masculinity, femininity and power interact, are as responsible for this mess, as the personal actions of those involved.
(First published in the Gomantak Times, 16 June 2010)
Itinerant mendicant captures two aspects of my life perfectly. My educational formation has seen me traverse various terrains, geographical as well as academic. After a Bachelor's in law from the National Law School of India, I worked for a while in the environmental and developmental sector. Following a Master's in the Sociology of Law, I obtained a Doctorate in Anthropology in Lisbon for my study of the citizenship experience of Goan Catholics. Having worked some years at the Centre for Research in Anthropology at the University Institute of Lisbon, I am now a priest for the Archdiocese of Goa and Daman.I see myself as a mendicant largely because so many of my voyages have been funded by scholarships and grants.This blog operates as an archive of my homilies, and writings in the popular press.